fbpx Lawyer's comment. The legality of the procedure for appointing the Head of the Commission is in question | Gamingpost.net

Lawyer's comment. The legality of the procedure for appointing the Head of the Commission is in question


Anna Buyagi, Managing Partner of VigoLex Law Firm, gave several comments on the legality of the appointment of the Head and Members of the Gambling and Lotteries Regulatory Commission.
  • Gambling legalization
  • 2020-11-02 10:28:34
  • 1046
Lawyer's comment. The legality of the procedure for appointing the Head of the Commission is in question

The law on gambling came into force on August 13, 2020, which meant the need to create a Commission for the supervision of the gambling market within the next 2 months. The regulation of gambling has become one of the most pressing issues. The work of the Cabinet was not long in coming: on September 23, an official statement on the creation of such a Commission was issued.

However, another "but" came - a collision, which was formed in one of the articles of the law. In one part, it is indicated that the competition for the selection of members of the Commission should be conducted by the Cabinet of Ministers with the involvement of candidates from the relevant committee. In another part, it is said that this should be a commission from the highest corps of the civil service according to the general procedure for the selection of civil servants.

Anna Buyadzhi, Managing Partner of VigoLex Law Firm, comments:

"However, even this miscalculation of the legislator is not the biggest problem now, since the government decided to act with lightning speed and according to the" third "procedure, which is not at all provided in the law on gambling. So, on October 5, 2020, the Cabinet of Ministers accepted an order "On the need to appoint the Chairman of the Commission for the Regulation of Gambling and Lotteries." It is clear from the text of the document that the National Agency for Civil Service should consider the documents of those who wishing to take part in the selection and then submit them to the Minister of the Cabinet of Ministers for interviewing the candidates."

On October 6 of this year, the corresponding vacancies appeared on the Single Portal of Civil Service Vacancies, and the deadline for submitting documents was set for October 12.

“Having considerable experience in preparing, filling out and submitting documents for various high government positions, I will say that it is almost impossible to collect a full set of documents in such a short time. At the same time, candidates still need to fill out an electronic declaration of their property status, which is also not an easy task. I suppose that such short deadlines for submission of documents may indicate that the persons holding the positions of the chairman and members of the commission were already known in advance, and they already had the necessary package of documents. "

These are just assumptions, but there are other questions as well. Where is the open and transparent competition? Why candidates did not pass tests for knowledge of legislation and for abstract thinking, as defined by the Law of Ukraine "On Civil Service"? Parliamentarians say that the appointment procedure has been changed because of the established quarantine measures. So, for the period of quarantine and 30 days after its end, the procedure for temporary selection for civil service positions will be in force by concluding a fixed-term contract.

"From the analysis of the order on the appointment of the Chairman of the Commission, we can assume that the procedure for appointment by concluding a contract is applied, although this order does not contain a direct reference to the specified procedure. Thus, the selection of commission members should take place according to some original procedure, not provided for by the current legislation, by "conducting an interview" by the Minister of the Cabinet of Ministers. And this does not seem to be a violation. At the same time, I have reasonable doubts about the legality of such actions.

The Law on the State Budget temporarily suspended the norms of the Law of Ukraine “On Civil Service” and the Law “On Central Executive Bodies”, but by no means the Law on Gambling, which defines a special procedure for the election and appointment of commission members. So, in my opinion, the order on the appointment of the chairman of the commission, where the special procedure is applied, is at least contested, and at the most - frankly illegal, since it was accepted contrary to the mandatory provisions of the law on gambling. "

Source: LoginCasino.

Let us remind: the legality of the gambling business in Ukraine was established with the acceptance of the relevant bill in the second reading at a meeting of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on July 14, 2020.

Legalization of gambling in Ukraine: The gambling business in Ukraine is ready to financially support the spheres of sports, culture and medicine.

Gambling business news in Ukraine: Anti-corruption expertise of the Law of Ukraine "On Amendments to the Tax Code of Ukraine regarding taxation of income from activities related to the organization and conduct of gambling and lotteries"

All the latest news from the gambling industry can be viewed on the gamingpost.net news portal about the gambling business.

YOU MUST PAY ATTENTION
"The only way is to expand the list," - Artem Kuzmenko on the certification of gambling equipment Gambling legalization

"The only way is to expand the list," - Artem Kuzmenko on the certification of gambling equipment

On Monday, KRAIL acepted a list of companies that can certify gambling equipment. It included 5 companies. Artem Kuzmenko, a lawyer and partner of ETERNA LAW, spoke specifically for Gamingpost.net about why this can become a problem, what to do for operators who have already received certificates from other companies, and whether such a list is needed at all.

  • 2021-04-27 15:20:39
  • 109
"From the first day - more than 150 applications for subscription", - Igor Romanyuk about the new release of the magazine "Azart" Gambling legalization

"From the first day - more than 150 applications for subscription", - Igor Romanyuk about the new release of the magazine "Azart"

The "Azart" magazine has been published since 2004. But after the gambling business was banned in Ukraine in 2009, the publication had to stop its work. 12 years later - "Azart" presents a fresh issue. He is both 1st and 60th. Publisher Igor Romanyuk exclusively for Gamingpost.net spoke about the ambitious goals of "Azart", a closed club and a limited edition of the magazine.

  • 2021-04-12 11:51:26
  • 364
Behind the scenes of Las Vegas casinos: how much do licenses cost in Nevada? Gambling legalization

Behind the scenes of Las Vegas casinos: how much do licenses cost in Nevada?

Las Vegas receives millions of tourists every year. And the state of Nevada receives millions of dollars in treasury revenues. How the gambling business of Nevada works - Gamingpost.net learned from the lawyer Yuri Porokhnavets, who lives and works in the USA. How much does it cost to open a casino in Nevada and what taxes do you have to pay? Read in an exclusive interview.

  • 2021-04-06 10:37:23
  • 394
“It is impossible to fill the budget by UAH 7,4 billion only through licenses,” - experts on the gambling market Gambling legalization

“It is impossible to fill the budget by UAH 7,4 billion only through licenses,” - experts on the gambling market

At the traditional round table on the development of the gambling business in Ukraine, experts discussed the certification of equipment, licenses for land-based business and revenues to the country's budget. Why can't the treasury of Ukraine be able to receive 7.4 billion hryvnias from licenses alone? Watch the report from Gamingpost.net.

  • 2021-04-06 10:28:58
  • 358
What are the differences between the gambling business of Ukraine and Georgia? Expert videoconference report Gambling legalization

What are the differences between the gambling business of Ukraine and Georgia? Expert videoconference report

International Advisers Associations representatives Alexander Lysyi and Andrey Reun, together with Talentgrator Marketing Director Lavrentiy Gubin, discussed the problems of starting the Ukrainian gambling market. This includes the registration of trademarks, and the problems of working with banks, certification and taxes. Why did the gambling market start much easier in Georgia? Read the Gamingpost.net report.

  • 2021-03-30 14:45:38
  • 483
Stars for hotels. When will the new certification of Ukrainian hotels start working? Gambling legalization

Stars for hotels. When will the new certification of Ukrainian hotels start working?

On March 16, the first meeting of the Commission for the establishment of hotel categories will take place. 75 hotels are already awaiting confirmation of their "stars", which they could not receive for more than a year. Among them are those hotels that are planning to open a casino or gambling halls. Vitaliy Fedorchenko, the founder of the Welcomer Network, spoke especially for Gamingpost.net about when Ukrainian hotels will be able to be classified according to the European model.

  • 2021-03-17 10:22:44
  • 479
More contents